Donate
  • About
  • Rent College Pads
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
Search
News
Opinions
Sports
Classifieds
Comics
BMA
Events
Subscribe

Friday, August 12, 2022
Print Archive

Eastern Echo
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
  • Search
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
Search

Subscribe to the Echo

Donate to The Echo

You can support the Echo by donating through the EMU Foundation and selecting to apply your gift to a specific fund. Any of the funds listed below will provide support to the Echo.

01049 -- EMU Echo Editor Endowed Scholarship:  Provides financial support for the current EMU Echo Editor.

02414 -- Scott Stephenson Eastern Echo Scholarship:  This expendable scholarship is for the benefit of student(s) in the School of Communication, Media & Theater Arts in the College of Arts & Sciences.  It will be awarded to a full or part-time junior or senior EMU student majoring in journalism and working for the Eastern Echo.  The student should be working to self-finance their education and not be eligible for need-based grants.

00825 -- Student Media Development:  Provides support for the Student Media program.

Thank you for supporting the Echo and EMU Student Media.

Give Now


6/9/2020, 10:59am

Opinion: Now is the time for data-driven, common sense police reform

With the new consensus around the need for police reform, it's important to explore ways to innovate and improve our police forces while also understanding and navigating hurdles.

By Heather Weigel
Opinion: Now is the time for data-driven, common sense police reform

Photo by Koshu Kunii on Unsplash

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Mail
  • Print

The past two weeks have seen collective mourning of George Floyd, collective action in urban, suburban, and rural communities in response, and a surprising level of consensus from Americans on the need for systemic reform in law enforcement. 

It is an important time to get something done and to take advantage of this consensus. It is an important time to listen to the calls of activists and explore ways to better our policing.

The most radical of these calls has been to “abolish the police,” which has actually been pledged by a veto-proof majority of the Minneapolis City Council, yet rejected by Major Jacob Frey and Democratic nominee for president Joe Biden. Dissenters typically point to more incremental reforms. But many who embrace the call to defund or abolish the police, including a Minneapolis councilwoman, have pointed to a perceived futility in this brand of reform. 

Past reforms of police forces in cities across the United States have had mixed results, as outlined in an episode of the FiveThirtyEight politics podcast, potentially buttressing this claim. However, much of the failures of reform fall on the disproportionate power of police unions even as police chiefs and community leaders vow to implement sweeping changes. This power dynamic is important as city councils, state legislatures, and Congress weigh in on what changes can be made at each level. 

To do this, officials need to turn to data on excessive force by the police in their cities, states, and the nation at large to evaluate the scope of the problem. A problem arises when considering that there is no national system for reporting police misconduct. To exacerbate the problem, state agencies are reluctant to release details of police misconduct. This leaves the research up to journalists and activists, which elected officials don’t always take as seriously as nationally collected and verified data. 

Further, oversight boards on the local level often have little-to-no enforcement power, allowing repeat offenders of police misconduct to never face real consequences. Even when officers face lawsuits, the money comes from the department and doesn’t impact their operations significantly, allowing departments to justify keeping officers on the force.

We can turn, however, to the data and proposals out there, like Campaign Zero, which provides a thorough outline of meaningful reforms. Among them are reforms which fall short of abolition, including updated training requirements like those which were passed in the Michigan Senate, community oversight, and limiting use-of-force (chokehold bans, comprehensive reporting, etc), among others. 

Restrictive Use-of-Force policies have shown to reduce police violence when they are enabled to be passed, according to Campaign Zero.

Previous attempts at reform in Minneapolis have undoubtedly failed. Lack of transparency and accountability on the behalf of police departments and a lack of enforcement power by oversight boards and police chiefs have created a sense of powerlessness by those truly trying to change the system. It may be appropriate for Minneapolis to scrap the MPD and rebuild, possibly developing into the community-based model of Camden, New Jersey. (There is still no consensus on what disbanding the MPD will amount to, or a straightforward estimate on the timeline.) 

But while all communities are not obligated to do the same, it is important to continue implementing reform even if it’s just short of what activists are advocating for. Use-of-force limitations, taking on police unions, updating training requirements, and empowering oversight committees and reformists are just a few things that can be done as we enter a new era of consensus on the need for police reform. It cannot be an all-or-nothing approach.

Much of what needs to be done may not require disbanding of forces, but may require disentangling the relationships which enable police officers to escape accountability, like the closeness of prosecutors and the police, the tendency of judges and juries to believe officers when they claim their life was being threatened (even by unarmed civilians), the lack of financial accountability for individual officers in lawsuits addressing excessive force, the stranglehold police unions have on local departments and their capacity for reform, and the lack of a non-threatening presence by officers in communities. It may require intervening in the relationship between the military and police, preventing local forces from becoming over-militarized. 

It is up to local departments to evaluate where their needs are, but it is also up to Congress and state legislatures to incentivize reforms, which may complicate the notion of defunding police. Reallocation of funds to rehabilitative structures as opposed to punitive ones is important to consider, but most reforms do require investment. Governmental structures, then, should be smart about itemizing what funds are to be used for in order to make police funding more effective. Any increase in police funding should see a match in preventative services, schools, etc., or specifically go towards more advanced training.

There is much that can be done without resorting to the most “radical” suggestions - notably, “lesser” reforms have been effective in some cities, especially when implemented as a response to public outcry, and these reforms are more likely to pass in a time of consensus. Now is an immensely important time to seek real reform and find consensus with unlikely allies to get there. 

We need common sense police reform, and the Left needs to work with allies instead of shooting themselves in the foot because their most radical demands won’t be met everywhere and their vision of a disbanded police force in Minneapolis might not line up with what actually ensues. Stressing accountability on behalf of police departments across the nation, chiefly by taking on police unions, eliminating qualified immunity, and constructing real and powerful oversight bodies, should not be underestimated or laughed at - there’s real potential for these to take hold and make a real difference. “Defund the Police” and related messaging should not detract from that, and I’m praying it doesn’t.

Share



Related Stories

Protesters block the intersection of Hogback Rd., Capenter Rd. and Washtenaw Ave. (continued)

Opinion: No, the Black Lives Matter protests are not an extension of Bernie's electoral "revolution"

By Heather Weigel

Riot police surround the perimeter of Schenely Park during an anti-police brutality demonstration.

Opinion: Riots over George Floyd’s death won’t tarnish his legacy, they’ll cement it in history 

By Fenrik Goerlitz

NAACP President Kya Fordham reads off the list of demands of affected students at today's rally.

Recent Campus Hate Incident Displays EMU’s Lack of Protective Policy

By Malaya Elgarico and Arica Frisbey


The Eastern Echo welcomes thoughtful discussion on all of our stories, but please keep comments civil and on-topic. Read our full guidelines here.


Most Popular


8/9/2022, 8:00am

Ypsilanti Town Recreation Department hosting first annual cornhole tournament

By Anyara Zapata

Top three teams at the corn hole tournament have a chance to win a cash prize.


8/8/2022, 8:15am

7th annual Heritage car show returns on August 13th at Gene Butman Ford


8/8/2022, 8:18am

Opinion: Mo Pop Festival is back from the ashes


8/9/2022, 8:00am

Review: ‘Not Okay’ is a social media satire film


Podcast


2/26/2022, 7:45pm

Podcast: February 23rd, 2022


5/14/2022, 6:20pm

Podcast: May 14th, 2022


4/22/2022, 11:14am

Podcast: April 21, 2022


4/14/2022, 9:26am

Podcast: April 14, 2022


Tweets by TheEasternEcho
Eastern Michigan Echo To Homepage
  • About
  • Jobs
  • Freelance
  • Submissions
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Distribution

All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2022 The Eastern Echo

Powered by Solutions by The State News.