Women's attire in Islam is personal expression
The hijab.
What is usually the first thing that comes to mind when you hear the word? Be honest with yourself. No one can hear your thoughts. Do you know what a hijab is? Do you know why it has to be worn?
A young Muslim woman begs for money at an outdoor market in Saint-Denis, France. In 2004, the French government imposed a law banning the public display of religion, including the hijab, in schools.
Possibly related:
- Tech a relationship nuisance · Dec 14
- Letter to the Editor: Gaddafi · Nov 2
- Budget matter of quality vs. price · Oct 23
- Abortion discussion complex · Oct 19
- 'We need to teach values' · Sep 11
If you don’t know this, it’s OK. But in light of the recent law banning French Muslim women from wearing the “burqa,” and the ban on the hijab – that has been in place since September 2004 – I think it is important to know a little bit more about what is going on in France and with the many Muslim women living there.
In September 2004, former President Jacques Chirac imposed a specific law forbidding people from showing any signs of religion – including the Islamic headscarf (veil), Jewish Kippa, and the Christian cross – in schools. This law, which was originally known as the secular law, is now also known as the “veil law.”
Small signs of religious affiliation are allowed, such as a small cross, Star of David or hand of Fatima, but nothing else. Because the hijab is considered an outward showing of religion, it was banned in public schools.
According to the current president of France, Nicholas Sarkozy, “we are a secular state.”
Now, I hate to disagree with President Sarkozy, but the United States is also a secular state, and people are not denied the right to dress according to their religious belief.
They are not denied any sort of privilege because they wear a headscarf, and they have not had fewer opportunities in life because of it.
If the hijab hasn’t stopped them from achieving their goals, why should it matter in a country such as France?
It seems, however, France’s being a secular state is not the only reason for the law. President Sarkozy also addresses the so-called problem of the hijab/burqa by saying, “It’s a sign of subservience, a sign of debasement…
“In our country, we cannot accept that women be prisoners behind a screen, cut off from all social life, deprived of all identity.”
How exactly does he know women are being forced to wear the hijab?
Did he ask the women if they are being forced?
Did he get some sort of opinion, since France is a democratic country?
If he had, then he would have been told Muslim women who cover are doing so out of choice, not force. A covered Muslim woman chooses to wear the hijab because it defines her as a Muslim. It is her way of expressing herself, just as a Goth wears all black or a nun wears a habit.
Belgian Senator Alain Destexhe said, “We want individuals to be integrated, and we want Muslim women to be viewed and treated as equals.” Destexhe was not the only person to express this. But since it was mentioned by him, it is quite necessary to say – all women in America, Muslim or not, are ‘viewed and treated as equals,’ regardless of what they wear.
Wearing a headscarf here does not stop a woman from receiving a proper education or a well-paid job. Speaking as a Muslim woman who wears the hijab, I can safely say I have never been treated differently because of the way I dress.
Not only that, but laws restricting the way a women should dress goes against the French view of freedom of expression.
According to an Untap’d article on July 27, 2009, “Telling someone to remove her Hijab…… in the name of unity is like telling everyone of colored skin to turn white. It would make the world a boring, unreal place.” I couldn’t agree more.
So, if the United States, also a secular state, is able to treat its citizens equally, no matter their beliefs, without making a hijab ban, then I think a country like France can do it as well.








by truth be told
France and other liberal/secular nations women may have a choice, true. Agreed. However, in other nations where Sharia law is in place, there is no choice for women. Women are forced to wear it otherwise they could be severely punished.
And another fact that expressing religious signs in the US classrooms is not highly smiled upon. Just ask the ACLU!
Even working for British Airways you cannot display religious symbols.
This is life in the secular/liberal world.
Flag for moderationby Iftikhar
I have seen western educated Muslim women are in Burqa while their mothers never even covered their heads in Pakistan. I do not know whether it is due to western education or because they find themselves victim of racism. According to Lord Burtend Russell, western education makes a man stupid and selfish. The credit cruch in the world is due to the policies of blue eyed western educated elites. British schooling is also in a mess because of such western educated elites.
Burqa is not locking women, it is a buffer line between protecting chasity and exposing. Being naked and drunk is acceptabl but being covered and modest is inhuman.
French president wants Muslim women to be topless like his wife who posed topless in fashion shows. He has no right to ban the burqa because it is undemocratic and an unqualified attack on individual freedom. Burqa is not just a piece of cloth but a lot of ideological and cultural connotation to it. Women are just being exploited in the name of rights. Burqa protects women’s rights and treat each women like a princess. No one has the right to ban the freedom of choice in a secular and democratic country. The right to choice is a basic fundamental right the person should have.
French president’s interpretation of burqa as a symbol of subservience is false. It is a usual habit of western ideologists to twist history and distort the facts inorder to project their culture as superior one. The president should be criminally tried for spreading such falsehood. To veil or not to veil should be an individual choice. Dress codes are for children, not for adults. Government legislated dress codes for the Taliban religious policy not western democracies. Women should be free to wear burqas. If women can get away with wearing cropped shirts and pants that show their panties, they should be able to waer burqas too.
One Muslim woman, Caroline Chaiima, writing in Lepoint.fr, said she wore a veil: “Let those most closely concerned speak. I am a French woman born in France, with French parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, and I am a Muslim. I wear the full veil and I feel like saying: So what? I am happy behind the veil, I protect myself from depraved stares. Neither my father, nor my brother, nor my husband forced the full veil upon me; it’s a personal choice.”
Flag for moderationIftikhar Ahmad
London School of Islamics Trust
www.londonschoolofislamics.org.uk