• About
  • Rent College Pads
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
Search
News
Opinions
Sports
Classifieds
Comics
BMA
Events
Subscribe

Donate

Eastern Echo

Tuesday, January 26, 2021 Print Edition

Subscribe

  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Profiles
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
  • Search
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Profiles
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
Search

Subscribe to the Echo

Donate to The Echo

You can support the Echo by donating through the EMU Foundation and selecting to apply your gift to a specific fund. Any of the funds listed below will provide support to the Echo.

01049 -- EMU Echo Editor Endowed Scholarship:  Provides financial support for the current EMU Echo Editor.

02414 -- Scott Stephenson Eastern Echo Scholarship:  This expendable scholarship is for the benefit of student(s) in the School of Communication, Media & Theater Arts in the College of Arts & Sciences.  It will be awarded to a full or part-time junior or senior EMU student majoring in journalism and working for the Eastern Echo.  The student should be working to self-finance their education and not be eligible for need-based grants.

00825 -- Student Media Development:  Provides support for the Student Media program.

Thank you for supporting the Echo and EMU Student Media.

Give Now


9/2/2014, 5:24pm

Art or Assets?

By James Tatum

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Mail
  • Print

When the Delaware Art Museum sold William Holman Hunt’s “Isabella and the Pot of Basil” they earned $4.25 million as well as the opprobrium of the art community. The Association of Art Museum Directors formally sanctioned the museum in June, and instructed its fellow members not to lend artwork to the Delaware Art Museum.

On July 18, 2013, the city of Detroit filed for Chapter 9 bankruptcy after decades of social and industrial decline, with an accumulated $18 billion in debt. Immediately, there was speculation that the city’s art collection, housed in the Detroit Institute of Arts, could be up for sale in order to settle the city’s debts.

That speculation was not completely unfounded. Syncora Guarantee Inc. and Financial Guaranty Insurance Company, two firms that had insured many of the municipal bonds that the city had defaulted on clamored for the art to be sold in order to stem their own losses. Many commentators also made the case that the city could not save its art, while it abandoned pensioners.

Kevyn Orr, the emergency manager appointed to correct the city’s finances by Gov. Rick Snyder of Michigan, commissioned the auction house Christie’s to appraise the art in the DIA. Christie’s appraisal was limited to pieces directly owned by the city, and yet still came to Orr with an estimate of $454 million to $867 million.

A second appraisal, which was more expansive, conducted by Artvest Partners at the behest of other creditors said the art collection was worth $4.6 billion. A third appraisal conducted by Victor Weiner Associates, hired by Financial Guaranty, said the art collection was worth $8.5 million.

Larger and larger numbers projected by the multiple appraisers don’t increase the enticement to sell the artwork; they decrease it. The differences in the estimates only further prove the speculative nature of the proposition. In fact, the report by Artvest Partners noted that the art collection may fetch much less than anticipated upon sale because the market would be flooded with so many pieces at once depressing prices.

And the $4.25 million that the Delaware Art Museum earned was half of the estimated $8.4 million and $13.4 million it was supposed to earn according to Christie’s.

The case of the Delaware Art Museum offers a contemporary example for those inside and outside of the city who think the art collection should be sold. Not only did the sale fail to raise the expected sum, it isn’t even close to what is needed by the museum to pay off debt from an expansion undertaken in 2005.

The Delaware Art Museum is prepared to sell more art in order to pay down debt, which is a no, no in the art community. And that community matters, for it has already inflicted sanctions on a museum that not only relies on the interest of the broader public, but deep-pocketed individuals in particular.

More to the point, like the Delaware Art Museum’s auction failed to solve its financial troubles, so to would the sale of the DIA’s work fail to make the city solvent. This is partly why Steven Rhodes, the federal bankruptcy judge overseeing Detroit’s case, has opposed the sale of the art. Because it doesn’t improve the city’s fiscal health in any way, and that matters to the process.

“Notwithstanding any power of the court, unless the debtor consents or the plan so provides, the court may not, by any stay, order, or decree, in the case or otherwise, interfere with any of the political or governmental powers of the debtor,” says subsection 904 of subchapter I of Chapter 9 bankruptcy. The statute continues to say that the court may not interfere with “any of the property or revenues of the debtor; or the debtor’s use or enjoyment of any income-producing property.”

In other words, neither creditors such as Syncora Guarantee and Financial Guaranty nor the federal bankruptcy court can order Detroit, the debtor, to sell the artwork.

It is in the spirit of the law that the quality of life of citizens be taken into consideration as well as monies owed to creditors. The loss of what can be called one of the America’s most encyclopedic collections of art does not improve the quality of life in the city.

The end result of the bankruptcy is for the city to exit the process better able to handle its debts, and serve its citizens.

Even before the crisis in Detroit, the American public has made its decision on whether art is art or an asset. Once art, public art, is transformed into a financial asset, unlike any other traded on the NASDAQ or Dow Jones, it has truly lost its value.

Share



Related Stories

sean-foley-qwlkNzlDf5I-unsplash.jpg

Review: Cyberpunk 2077 doesn't live up to the hype

By Caleb Burlingame

Photo by Todd Greene on Unsplash.

Opinion: Predicting each number one seed for the NCAA tournament

By Caleb Burlingame

clem turner screenshot

Review: I fell in love with Clem Turner's music, I think you will too

By Chelsea Bacci


The Eastern Echo welcomes thoughtful discussion on all of our stories, but please keep comments civil and on-topic. Read our full guidelines here.


Most Popular


1/24/2021, 9:29pm

Campus-Area Crime Map: Jan. 13 through Jan. 23

By Tyler Gaw

The campus–area crime map is a report of criminal activity that has been reported in the Ypsilanti-area as well as on the campus of Eastern Michigan University.


1/20/2021, 1:08pm

Eastern Michigan University students launch job search website to fill roles at small businesses in the Ypsilanti and the Downriver community


1/24/2021, 9:31pm

Review: I fell in love with Clem Turner's music, I think you will too


1/24/2021, 9:37pm

Review: Cyberpunk 2077 doesn't live up to the hype


Podcast


1/23/2021, 3:24pm

The Factory Report: Volleyball is back!


1/21/2021, 2:55pm

Podcast: January 20, 2020


1/17/2021, 9:00pm

The Road to the Mac Tournament For EMU Men’s and Women’s Basketball


1/14/2021, 7:11pm

Documentary features EMU student artists' experiences amidst COVID-19 pandemic


Tweets by TheEasternEcho
Eastern Michigan Echo To Homepage
  • About
  • Jobs
  • Freelance
  • Submissions
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Distribution

All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2021 The Eastern Echo

Powered by Solutions by The State News.