Donate
  • About
  • Rent College Pads
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
Search
News
Opinions
Sports
Classifieds
Comics
BMA
Events
Subscribe

Thursday, March 23, 2023
Print Archive

Eastern Echo
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
  • Search
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Comics
  • Podcast
  • BMA
  • Events
  • Classifieds
Search

Subscribe to the Echo

Donate to The Echo

You can support the Echo by donating through the EMU Foundation and selecting to apply your gift to a specific fund. Any of the funds listed below will provide support to the Echo.

01049 -- EMU Echo Editor Endowed Scholarship:  Provides financial support for the current EMU Echo Editor.

02414 -- Scott Stephenson Eastern Echo Scholarship:  This expendable scholarship is for the benefit of student(s) in the School of Communication, Media & Theater Arts in the College of Arts & Sciences.  It will be awarded to a full or part-time junior or senior EMU student majoring in journalism and working for the Eastern Echo.  The student should be working to self-finance their education and not be eligible for need-based grants.

00825 -- Student Media Development:  Provides support for the Student Media program.

Thank you for supporting the Echo and EMU Student Media.

Give Now


6/7/2015, 11:14am

States should abolish the death penalty

By Alison Basley

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Mail
  • Print

On Wednesday, The New York Times reported that Nebraska became the 19th state to abolish the death penalty, along with the District of Columbia. It is the first predominantly Republican state to abolish capital punishment in more than 40 years. This is an encouraging trend because the death penalty is costly, immoral, dangerous and ineffective at deterring crime.

According to Conservatives Concerned About the Death Penalty, “More than a dozen states have tried to capture the cost of death penalty cases and found evidence that they are up to 10 times more expensive than other comparable cases. In California, a 2011 study showed death penalty cases are 20 times more expensive. That state has spent over $4 billion on the death penalty since 1978.” From 1980 until 2012, only 13 people were executed in California.

The costs come from a more thorough legal process with more legal actors and safeguards in place because of the possibility of death row. CCADP found that most death penalty trials are eventually found to be significantly flawed and must be redone, sometimes more than once, adding to the total cost. Plus, if the penalty is never imposed, taxpayers are saddled with the cost regardless.

As a consequence of these costs, services like police and highway funding or counseling for homicide survivors are neglected. CCADP cited a case in Jasper County, Texas where they had to raise property taxes by 7 percent just to pay for a single death penalty case.

In addition, a 2009 study done by Michael L. Radelet and Traci L. Lacock found that “the consensus among criminologists is that the death penalty does not add any significant deterrent effect above that of long-term imprisonment.” Indeed, 88 percent of respondents concluded it is not a deterrent to murder.

Moreover, The Death Penalty Information Center concluded – using murder rates from the FBI’s “Crime in the United States” from 1990 to 2009 – that the murder rate in non-death penalty states has remained consistently lower than the rate in states with the death penalty and that the gap has grown since 1990.

Perhaps the most concerning aspect of the death penalty is the likelihood of innocent people being sentenced to death. The danger will always be the possibility of human error or actual intent to damage a defendant's case.

CCADP reported that “Since 1973, at least 150 people have been freed from death row after evidence of innocence revealed that they had been wrongfully convicted. That’s almost one person exonerated for every ten who’ve been executed.” These developments are mainly due to advancements in DNA analysis or increased use of it in criminal cases.

But even scientific evidence can work against a defendant if crime labs commit fraud, such as in the case of Curtis McCarty in 1986 as reported by Professor Jason Brennan in April for Learn Liberty. McCarty was exonerated in 2007 after it was found that a forensic chemist with the Oklahoma City Police Department either intentionally altered or lost evidence related to the case.

One small mistake, even if committed by unintentional human error, can be deadly.

Last comes the question of morality, since capital punishment cases can be quite emotional for the defendant and victims’ communities and families.

We must ask ourselves, “Should the government kill?” The state’s first role, arguably its only one, is protecting the lives and property of its citizens.

Furthermore, state-sanctioned murder, or the “an eye-for-an-eye” conviction of justice, ignores a more fundamental question. Even if you feel someone deserves to die, should we be trusting the state with such a power as deciding who lives and who dies?

Currently, over 3,000 people await execution in the U.S. Even if we believe some or most of them deserve death, can we really trust the government or fellow humans when they declare all are guilty, or that no mistakes have been made?

Share



Related Stories

Tormenta Gorillaz Ft. Bad Bunny.jpg

Review: 'Tormenta' is a unique blend of reggaeton and rock jazz

By Gerliz Herrera

Eagle Crest Golf Course Sign

Eagle Crest Golf Club ranked 13th best college golf course in the country

By Alex Kreps

the-last-of-us-poster-2-1296.jpg

Review: The last of 'The Last of Us' season one is gripping

By Sydney Brown


The Eastern Echo welcomes thoughtful discussion on all of our stories, but please keep comments civil and on-topic. Read our full guidelines here.


Most Popular


3/20/2023, 8:00am

What's the move at EMU? March 20-23

By Victoria Smith

Check out these events happening on and around campus this week.


3/20/2023, 8:00am

EMU full time and part time lecturers combine to make one contract bargaining unit


3/17/2023, 12:00am

Opinion: Underrated songs from notorious emo bands


3/16/2023, 8:00am

Opinion: J.Cole's label Dreamville continues to go above and beyond


Podcast


3/2/2023, 11:36am

TheBlockE Podcast: Episode 12 - MAC Tournament Controversy


2/18/2023, 4:41pm

TheBlockE Podcast: Episode 11 - WHAT'S GOING ON?!


2/12/2023, 2:39pm

Echo Interviews: Kings of Color President Dylan Hughey discusses Black History Month


2/12/2023, 2:32pm

The Block E Podcast: Super Bowl Sunday


Tweets by TheEasternEcho
Eastern Michigan Echo To Homepage
  • About
  • Jobs
  • Freelance
  • Submissions
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Distribution

All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2023 The Eastern Echo

Powered by Solutions by The State News.