Sunday, February 12, 2012  | 32°F 7-Day Forecast

The Eastern Echo

News and nonsense spiced with nerve

The metro perspective: Universal health care

I was just reading about President Obama’s new push to pass his health care legislation and the republican opposition. It’s an interesting subject.

Supporters believe that every American should have health care. Opponents believe that universal health care means a lower standard of care for everyone and will plunge the country deeper into debt.

Amidst all of the political wrangling, however, there is one group of people who have been all but ignored: the uninsured.

Physicians claim that universal health care will require them to adopt an assembly-line approach to health care. They argue that they will be paid less to see patients, so they will have to see more patients to recoup their losses.
Lobbyists converge upon Washington and make their arguments why universal health care is good or bad for our country, whether it makes fiscal sense or not and how it threatens our democratic way of life.

In the meantime, people are dying from otherwise benign ailments, because they can’t afford an office visit or simple antibiotics.

There are people in this state who have no health care because they are unemployed, yet can’t get Medicaid because of a legislative loophole which disqualifies them. They certainly can’t afford private health care, nor can they afford to go to a doctor on their own.

While politicians and lobbyists jockey for political gain, real people suffer. Here is one of their stories.

Steven is a student at Eastern Michigan University. He is divorced and has two children. He returned to school after becoming disabled because he wanted to finish his degree. Since he couldn’t work, it seemed like a perfect time.

He went to the Department of Human Services to apply for state aid and he applied for disability benefits through Social Security. He was denied for both.

Steven has a good relationship with his ex and they had always taken care of child support between themselves. The state, however, would not approve benefits unless he dragged his ex into court to get a Friend of the Court ruling for child care payments. That also disqualified him from Medicaid or any other benefits.

Steven’s interest in maintaining a positive relationship with his ex for his childrens’ benefit cost him any help from the state.

Social Security, on the other hand, decided that he wasn’t really disabled because he was going to school. The Social Security Administration’s logic is that if he can go to school, he can work, so he doesn’t qualify for disability.

Apparently, the SSA requires disabled people to sit on their butts at home all day long.

Steven has no income, no savings, no assets, and has tapped out his available student loans, so he probably won’t be able to stay in school for very much longer. Of course, he also has no health care.

What happens if he gets sick? What if he slips on ice and breaks his arm? What if any of a million possible freak accidents happens to him?

While physicians’ lobbyist groups complain that universal health care will cost doctors money, a profession that averages a $280,400-per-year salary, because they will be paid less per patient, Steven has nothing. While doctors complain that they will have to see more patients to make up the difference, thereby meaning less individualized attention for each patient, Steven can’t even walk through a doctor’s front door.

Steven’s story is not unique. He is, unfortunately, in the same situation as a growing segment of our country’s population. He would give anything for one-tenth of a doctor’s average salary. He would be grateful for an abbreviated doctor’s visit, because it’s more than he has right now.

Politicians and lobbyists in Washington squabble over political posturing and partisanship while good people go without. These people seem to have lost sight of what really matters, though—the people.

While people can control a lot of things in their lives, whether they get sick or not isn’t one of them. While republicans and democrats bicker over principles, Steven sits at home, waiting and praying he doesn’t get sick.

I would encourage anyone who cares about his fellow Americans to write to your Congressman or Senator and encourage them to put aside partisanship for a moment and do the right thing.

Doctors swear to “remember that (they) remain a member of society, with special obligations to all (their) fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm,” when they take the Hippocratic Oath.

That seems to be an ideal they have misunderstood or lost sight of. Perhaps it’s time for physicians in this country to look back at that ancient oath and all it stands for, and renew their pledge to do their service for humanity.
Perhaps it’s an ideal we can all aspire to.

Find The Metro Perspective’s Fan page on Facebook.


  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • |
  • Print
  • Email
Section: Life
6 Comments
March 7 at 7:03 PM
by Dontfallforit

You are an idiot.

Flag for moderation
March 7 at 11:25 PM
by RoanaDallas

You can get full medical coverage at the lowest price from http://bit.ly/atGzeD

Flag for moderation
March 8 at 2:04 AM
by Howard

Becoming a doctor is a great undertaking, of which only the highest qualified students can achieve this career. So if you make them see twice the patients and pay them bad enough wages, you aren’t going to have a lot of people putting in the effort to become doctors.
Then you get the “C” students becoming doctors. I’d much rather prefer an “A” student handling my life, wouldn’t you?

And, riddle me this, why is “Steven” uneducated and has two kids??? That guy made some bad life decisions, now he has to deal with the consequences. The government can’t help him with that.

Furthermore, you point out how Social Security is messed up and refuses to help out our poor “Steven” due to judicial loopholes.
Just to let you know, social security is GOVERNMENT RUN.
Why on earth would you think that this new utopian health care system would be any different???

And, as a side note, I felt that I was grading an essay from a kid in junior high. You have lots of filler paragraphs that all say the EXACT SAME THING.
“While the government fights over issues, the people suffer” OVER AND OVER.

I suggest you learn to write properly before you play journalist.

Flag for moderation
March 8 at 2:06 AM
by Howard

Becoming a doctor is a great undertaking, of which only the highest qualified students can achieve this career. So if you make them see twice the patients and pay them bad enough wages, you aren’t going to have a lot of people putting in the effort to become doctors.
Then you get the “C” students becoming doctors. I’d much rather prefer an “A” student handling my life, wouldn’t you?

And, riddle me this, why is “Steven” uneducated and has two kids??? That guy made some bad life decisions, now he has to deal with the consequences. The government can’t help him with that.

Furthermore, you point out how Social Security is messed up and refuses to help out our poor “Steven” due to judicial loopholes.
Just to let you know, social security is GOVERNMENT RUN.
Why on earth would you think that this new utopian health care system would be any different???

And, as a side note, I felt that I was grading an essay from a kid in junior high. You have lots of filler paragraphs that all say the EXACT SAME THING.
“While the government fights over issues, the people suffer” OVER AND OVER.

I suggest you learn to write properly before you play journalist.

Flag for moderation
March 8 at 3:15 AM
by RoanaDallas

Find instant medical insurance for you from http://bit.ly/atGzeD

Flag for moderation
March 9 at 8:40 AM
by Ignatius

Howard,

In Canada, we have universal health care. We also have many qualified doctors who are paid quite well. They also do not take an assembly line approach to patients, and aren’t forced to see more patients.

As for disability and social services, we have a system where the disabled are encouraged to go back to school in order to learn a new trade or career that they are able to do with their disability. It is about enabling the disabled, rather than providing for them. Most disabled people don’t want to be receiving money from the government – they want to earn it. But most find themselves in careers and lifestyles that no longer fit with their new disability.

The problem with social services is not that it is government run, it is that Republican mentality has had its way with the programs and ensured that they are a continued failure and waste of money. They could easily be run better and cost the taxpayers less if only they weren’t sabotaged by people trying to make the opposite party look bad. (As is currently happening with the health care.)

Now, please try to avoid ad hominem attacks and Straw Man fallacies in your arguments. In fact, try responding with reasoned out, justified arguments rather than manipulative twists of the point. Your argument of, “Then you get the “C” students becoming doctors. I’d much rather prefer an “A” student handling my life, wouldn’t you?” is rife with fallacy, as the conclusion does not follow from the premise. “C” students are either already doctors now, or cannot become doctors, regardless of how much actual doctors get paid. Many doctors take up the profession for other reasons than money, which is a nice bonus. And finally, history has shown many examples of people who are successful at careers without being successful in an education environment (Einstein is the simplest one that comes to mind). I would want a qualified, successful doctor to treat me, regardless of their grades in University.

Flag for moderation

Leave a response

All fields are required.

 Your email address will not be published.
HTML is not allowed.
 What are the LAST three letters of the alphabet?
From the Blogs

Today's front page

front page

Upcoming Events
Today's top events
  • No events for this date
Monday's top events
  • No events for this date
Tuesday's top events
  • No events for this date
Wednesday's top events
  • No events for this date
Thursday's top events
  • No events for this date
Follow us
DS